Have you ever decided to withhold information from someone to protect something of value?
The “something of value” could be many things, including a physical asset, an opportunity, or a relationship.
My story for you is about a piece of jewelry.
I based it on actual events—some I observed and some I heard from the people involved. I didn’t change the premise. But I did take creative license in retelling what happened.
You’ll find a twist to the plot and questions to ponder at the end.
The Diamond Bumblebee
For several years, Grace’s favorite piece of jewelry was a diamond bumblebee brooch. She had spotted it in a jewelry store when she and her husband Jack stopped by the shop to have some prongs on her engagement ring tightened.
After trying it on for fun, Grace was stunned when Jack told the jeweler, “We’ll take it.” He went on to wish her an early happy anniversary. His spur-of-the-moment decision, which was so out of character, delighted her.
Known for his pragmatism, Jack made a wise purchase, and Grace knew it. The jeweler had priced the pin fairly, and the diamonds were good quality. As he handed the box to Grace, Jack was already thinking ahead, saying it would be a nice heirloom to pass down to Lily, their granddaughter.
Grace agreed but treasured the little bee for the simple joy of wearing it.
The Cost of Carelessness
Although she didn’t wear it to plant pansies or do loads of laundry, Grace often pinned the brooch to a casual jacket, sweater, or dress to add a bit of sparkle to an outfit for work or an outing with friends. The problem was that she’d absentmindedly leave it attached to whatever she’d worn. Too often, upon realizing that the bee was missing from her jewelry box, Grace would begin looking through her clothes until she found it.
She never admitted this to Jack, but Grace once found the bee hiding in a bedroom slipper on her closet floor. It had fallen off a blazer after she had hung it up. Luckily, the shoe’s fuzzy lining provided a soft landing.
The last time Grace went looking for the bee, she remembered wearing it on a yellow cardigan that had been dry cleaned. She decided not to ask the cleaners’ owners if they’d found it. For one thing, she was too embarrassed. For another, Grace had known the husband and wife for years, and they were not only honest but quite successful. They’d have no reason to pocket her brooch.
Considering where the bee might be, Grace searched every nook and cranny inside her home. Making herself crazy, she also looked in her car, throughout the garage, and anywhere outside she may have stepped while wearing the sweater.
Finally giving up, she revealed the misfortune to Jack.
“I feel just awful,” Grace said, adding, “not only for me but for Lily too.”
“Let’s see if it shows up,” Jack said. “No telling where it could be in this house.” He repeated the same words each time she mentioned the lost item … until she stopped.
Grace continued to miss her bumblebee and secretly hoped Jack would choose to replace it. To her disappointment, anniversaries came and went without any new jewelry.
The Rest of the Story
The original pin was never lost.
Jack learned of the mishap when he picked up the dry cleaning. That’s when the friendly proprietor handed over the sweater and the brooch.
“We owe you an apology,” he told Jack. “My wife was supposed to contact your wife as soon as we noticed the pin was on the sweater. We just realized that never happened,” he continued. “She was interrupted by a call from our son’s school. He was sick and needed to be picked up.”
His wife then approached the counter and said, “I’m so sorry. I left the store immediately and completely forgot about calling. But rest assured,” she went on, “we had it locked away in our lost-and-found cabinet the entire time.”
Jack smiled and thanked them for keeping it safe. Privately, he was extremely aggravated with Grace. Wondering if he could keep calm when he broke the news to her, Jack realized he didn’t have to tell her anything.
Before leaving the cleaners, he said, “Please don’t mention this to my wife. It would only upset her.” They agreed, assuming he would return the brooch to her without any drama.
The Hidden Truth
Indeed, when he got home, Jack said nothing. Instead, he hid the brooch in a false bottom of his desk drawer. He later told Lily what happened and where to find the pin, as it was hers to inherit. Maybe he intended to inform Grace at some point, but that never occurred before he passed away.
To avoid causing a rift between her grandparents, Lily kept Jack’s secret until he died. After, her first visit with her grandmother presented an opportunity for her to return the bumblebee in a way that would protect Grace’s feelings.
While her grandmother was preoccupied, Lily secretly removed the bumblebee from Jack’s desk and then tucked it in Grace’s sweater drawer. Several months later, Grace called Lily to say she had the best news ever.
“I found our bumblebee!” she exclaimed.
A Question of Values
I could share my thoughts on how the bumblebee brooch was handled, but I’d rather hear yours.
First, to appreciate Jack’s position, consider this:
In his professional life, he’d made countless risk assessments. Occasionally, decisions would impact some employees negatively, and Jack was sorry to burden them. Still, he expected everyone to adapt. He was doing what was best for the company.
Did he operate with a similar mindset in his personal life?
If so, Jack possibly believed that it was better for Grace to experience some temporary distress over thinking the pin was lost rather than for the family to lose the jewelry permanently. Putting the item away ensured that Lily would inherit it.
Maybe Jack underestimated how much the perceived loss hurt Grace. Or maybe he understood, but the premium he placed on the brooch was higher.
No matter his motivation, was Jack justified in keeping the brooch from Grace?
What could he have said and done differently?
And what about Lily?
Was she right to keep Jack’s secret by placing the pin in the sweater drawer for Grace to find?
The Value of Communicating
At times, protecting something of value can take priority over individual needs and desires.
That said, withholding facts under the guise of protection could very well be unethical.
While a forthright approach could pose different kinds of risks, an open and honest dialogue might also lead to better cooperation among everyone concerned; if so, perhaps the things and the people we value would benefit more fully.
Regarding the final thoughts, I wonder if either of our diamond bumblebee keepers considered the last two.
Sallie W. Boyles, a.k.a. Write Lady
Thoughts or questions? Please contact Sallie Boyles, owner of Write Lady Inc., to exchange ideas about effective communications and gain from professional writing and editing services. Receive monthly tips and insights by subscribing at https://WriteLady.com.